HomeFitnessThe Whoop Killer: Garmin's 955

The Whoop Killer: Garmin’s 955

Published on

Phoenix
clear sky
76.1 ° F
81.1 °
68.5 °
22 %
1.9mph
0 %
Tue
98 °
Wed
101 °
Thu
100 °
Fri
100 °
Sat
103 °

A couple of weeks ago I wondered if Garmin’s new Forerunning 955 would be a Whoop Killer? After a couple of weeks of use, I said I would report my experience. Just for background, I’ve used a Whoop band since 2018. During that time I also used a Garmin 945 for all my endurance sports training. With the inclusion of native, built-in recovery measuring and reporting in the new 955, I wondered if I would find it more (1) accurate and (2) useful than the data provided by Whoop.

I’ve now wore the 955 almost 24/7 for over three weeks which allows for the device to calibrate and provide full recovery metrics. I can say for me, without a doubt, both the accuracy and usefulness of the data is far superior to the Whoop. Here are both my positives and a few negatives, comparing only apples to apples (ie., if the Whoop doesn’t try to do it, I’m not using it as a factor):

Positives:

  1. The Elevate V4 Optical HR sensor is more accurate than the Whoop, especially when doing certain activities such as showering or other movements that cause a lot of wrist movement.
  2. The Training Readiness score is much more useful, as it takes in a number of multifaceted, secondary metrics, to produce an overall score. I’ve found it correlates much more to how I performed in training for that day.
  3. HRV readings give you both a nightly average and a more 40,000 foot view of our overall condition by taking into account multi-week trends in HRV. So, it give you a better idea of who fatigued you are, generally, and also how you might respond to training on a given day.
  4. During training accuracy of the 955 is far superior. I’m a triathlete so this is double so when in the water or while worn on the wrist during cycling.
  5. Battery life is better, which was a big complaint of my when switching from the 3.0 to 4.0.
  6. Price. I’m not a big subscription model guy and hate the number of companies moving to this model to slowly such more money from customers over years.

Negatives:

  1. Sleep tracking seems to be less accurate. I’m talking only recognizing when I feel asleep and woke up, not sleep cycles because I don’t believe any device is good at measuring such.
  2. Bigger and more cumbersome. There is something to be said for the minimalist design of the Whoop which I always loved. The 955 is more cumbersome to wear during daily activity, during certain stuff like Crossfit/BJJ, and while sleeping. Having said that, connecting a simple external HRM to your 955 is a fine work-around when you don’t want to wear the watch but still want data.
  3. Less durable. You still have a screen on your wrist you can brake.

When you try to make an apples to apples comparison to what both devices claim to do, I think the 955 is far superior. Then you add in all the other stuff it does, from detailed GPS tracking, to on-board music to help a user do a workout, I’m sold and I cancelled my Whoop subscription.

Latest articles

A Home for Wayward Cops

Two of my posts have garnered a lot of attention.  Between Friday’s With “Fired”...

Netflix’s Turning Point | Anti-American Trash

I watched Episode 1 of Turning Point on Netflix, a series about the Cold...

Road House (2024) | The Review

The most anticipated movie of 2024, and possibly the last decade, was released on...

The DOJ Doesn’t Know What They Are Talking About

The DOJ's targeting of Apple is bat shit crazy. Garland and the DOJ, during...

More like this

A Home for Wayward Cops

Two of my posts have garnered a lot of attention.  Between Friday’s With “Fired”...

Netflix’s Turning Point | Anti-American Trash

I watched Episode 1 of Turning Point on Netflix, a series about the Cold...

Road House (2024) | The Review

The most anticipated movie of 2024, and possibly the last decade, was released on...

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

A couple of weeks ago I wondered if Garmin's new Forerunning 955 would be a Whoop Killer? After a couple of weeks of use, I said I would report my experience. Just for background, I've used a Whoop band since 2018. During that time I also...The Whoop Killer: Garmin's 955